☀ SolarEvidence

Claims › The Sun & space weather › How strong would Solar Cycle 25 be? The prediction debate

How strong would Solar Cycle 25 be? The prediction debate

Status: Contested Verdict: Measured: Cycle 25 peaked above the 2019 panel forecast (160.9 vs. 115) but below record highs; which prediction model works best remains Contested

The claim: Solar Cycle 25 would be a weak cycle similar to Cycle 24 (the 2019 NOAA/NASA/ISES panel consensus). A competing 'terminator' method argued it could be one of the strongest on record.

Why this label: The real Sun settled the first half of this debate. Solar Cycle 25 peaked at a smoothed sunspot number of 160.9 (2024-10). That beat the official 2019 panel forecast of 105–125, while staying well below the all-time record of 285.0 (1958-03). Which forecasting method works best remains Contested.

Background

Predicting how strong an 11-year sunspot cycle will be is one of solar physics' toughest challenges. In 2019, an official NOAA/NASA panel combined nearly 50 forecasts and predicted a mild cycle peaking at 115 in July 2025. Meanwhile, a rival 'terminator' timing method by McIntosh and colleagues predicted a much stronger cycle. By 2024, the real Sun rose well above the panel's forecast, prompting NOAA to update its outlook.

NOAA chart of observed monthly sunspot numbers for Solar Cycle 25 against the official prediction range
NOAA's chart of observed Cycle 25 sunspot numbers against the official prediction. Image: NOAA, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Resized.

✓ Evidence and arguments for

  • The 2019 official consensus. The international panel predicted a mild peak of 115 sunspots (range 105–125), similar to weak Cycle 24. [1][2]
  • Polar magnetic field models. Surface flux-transport models (Upton & Hathaway 2018) used the strength of the Sun's polar fields at solar minimum and also predicted a mild cycle. [3]
  • The 'terminator' challenger. McIntosh and colleagues (2020) tracked the exact date when the old cycle's magnetic bands vanished ('the terminator') and predicted Cycle 25 would be much stronger than the consensus. [4]

🔬 Evidence and arguments against

  • The Sun beat the 2019 panel. NOAA's smoothed sunspot number reached 160.9 in 2024-10, beating Cycle 24's peak of 116.4 (2014-04) and topping the panel's 105–125 range. [5]
  • NOAA's 2023 upward revision. In 2023, NOAA updated its live forecast to a peak of 137–173 sunspots in 2024, matching what actually happened. [6]
  • Below the all-time record. While Cycle 25 was strong, it stayed well below the record smoothed peak of 285.0 (1958-03), so the highest 'top-tier record cycle' predictions also overshot. [5]
  • Solar maximum reached in 2024. On October 15, 2024, NASA and NOAA announced that the Sun had entered its maximum phase. [7]

Open questions & what would change the label

Does the terminator timing method capture a deeper magnetic clock inside the Sun? The upcoming forecast for Solar Cycle 26 (expected to start around 2029–2032) will be the next head-to-head test.

Primary Scientific Sources (7)

  1. NOAA SWPC: Solar Cycle 25 Forecast Update (panel consensus) https://www.spaceweather.gov/news/solar-cycle-25-forecast-update consensus
  2. NOAA SWPC: Solar Cycle Progression (panel details and live data) https://www.swpc.noaa.gov/products/solar-cycle-progression data
  3. Upton, L. A. & Hathaway, D. H. (2018). An Updated Solar Cycle 25 Prediction With AFT: The Modern Minimum. Geophysical Research Letters. doi:10.1029/2018GL078387 forecast
  4. McIntosh, S. W. et al. (2020). Overlapping Magnetic Activity Cycles and the Sunspot Number: Forecasting Sunspot Cycle 25 Amplitude. Solar Physics. doi:10.1007/s11207-020-01723-y forecast
  5. NOAA SWPC observed solar-cycle indices (JSON, smoothed SIDC sunspot number) https://services.swpc.noaa.gov/json/solar-cycle/observed-solar-cycle-indices.json data
  6. NOAA SWPC: NOAA forecasts quicker, stronger peak of solar activity (2023 revision) https://www.spaceweather.gov/news/noaa-forecasts-quicker-stronger-peak-solar-activity forecast
  7. NASA: NASA, NOAA: Sun Reaches Maximum Phase in 11-Year Solar Cycle (15 Oct 2024) https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/heliophysics/nasa-noaa-sun-reaches-maximum-phase-in-11-year-solar-cycle/ announcement

Further Reading (Both Sides of the Debate)

Vetted books covering both the mainstream baseline and Leading Edge perspectives on this topic. Browse all 18 solar and geomagnetic books on Books & Further Reading or visit our Search for the Truth Bookshop.org storefront.

Mainstream Baseline 2014 ★ 4.6/5

Nearest Star: The Surprising Science of Our Sun (2nd ed.)

Leon Golub & Jay M. Pasachoff · ISBN 9781107672642

A clear, readable tour of how the Sun works from the inside out. Two veteran solar astronomers explain core nuclear fusion, the 11-year sunspot cycle, solar flares, and billion-ton coronal mass ejections.

Why this book matters to both sides

Gives the standard physics baseline for how the Sun generates heat and magnetic storms. That you can compare against alternative Electric Sun and superflare ideas.

Mainstream Baseline 2015 ★ 4.7/5

The Sun's Influence on Climate

Joanna D. Haigh & Peter Cargill · ISBN 9780691153841

Two physicists explain how much the Sun's brightness and ultraviolet rays actually change over the 11-year sunspot cycle. They also test how much quiet-Sun periods (like the 1600s Maunder Minimum) cool Earth's climate.

Why this book matters to both sides

Directly addresses the 'Grand Solar Minimum / Mini Ice Age' debate using satellite measurements of solar output and upper-air winds.

Mainstream Baseline 2007 ★ 4.7/5

The Sun Kings: The Unexpected Tragedy of Richard Carrington and the Tale of How Modern Astronomy Began

Stuart Clark · ISBN 9780691141268

On September 1, 1859, British astronomer Richard Carrington saw a bright white flash on the Sun. Hours later, the biggest solar storm in modern history sparked telegraph lines and lit up red auroras over the tropics.

Why this book matters to both sides

Sets the real-world benchmark for a worst-case solar superstorm (the 1859 Carrington Event). Both modern power-grid engineers and solar-catastrophe writers measure their models against this storm.

Leading Edge 2012 ★ 4.7/5

Forgotten Civilization: New Discoveries on the Solar-Induced Dark Age (Revised ed.)

Robert M. Schoch with Catherine Ulissey · ISBN 9781644112922

Boston University geologist Robert Schoch presents his water-weathering case for an older Great Sphinx alongside his Leading Edge hypothesis that giant solar outbursts around 9700 BCE melted the Ice Age glaciers.

Why this book matters to both sides

The primary Leading Edge book arguing that an extreme solar superstorm—rather than a comet impact—ended the last Ice Age and left plasma patterns in ancient rock art.

FTC affiliate disclosure: Book links above go to Bookshop.org (Affiliate ID 130218, shop Search for the Truth), which supports independent bookstores. If you buy through one of these links, Solar Evidence earns a 10% commission at no extra cost to you. All affiliate links carry rel="sponsored nofollow noopener". Every recommended title is verified in print and meets our 4.3+/5 reader or landmark scholarly reputation standard; commissions never influence our evidence labels. Affiliate policy.

Interest signal: Wikipedia 'Solar cycle 25' averaged 5,257 views/month and 'Solar cycle' 9,050 (Oct 2025–Sep 2026). Sources were checked against Crossref/publisher pages on 2026-10-27. Labels describe the claim, not the people who hold it. Disclaimer.